Why cloud engineering collaboration tools are slow to ramp up

Why cloud engineering collaboration tools are slow to ramp up

cloud-engineering-collaboration-user-adoption

Few weeks ago I attended Boston Tech Jam and learn new buzzword – YAPSA. Which stands for Yet Another Photo Sharing Application. The amount of cloud files and data sharing applications is skyrocketing these days. It inspired many developers to re-think how to share and collaborate with engineering data.  Cloud technologies made people to bring back lots of web-collaboration initiatives from earlier 2000s. Web collaboration was hard 10 years ago.  IaaS  initial cost and availability made deployment and hosting of collaboration tools simple. 10 years of web 2.0  and photo sharing application experience provided good foundation of open source technologies to implement basic set of features. The straightforward set of every engineering collaboration is down to 5 basic functions: upload CAD files, web/mobile viewing, versions, project organization, comments and reviews.

So, you can ask me – what is wrong here? The challenge of all cloud based tools is user adoption. The obvious dream of every vendor in this space is to make tools to scale within organizations.  Here are few widely used associations and buzzwords – Dropbox for CAD, Facebook for engineers, Google Drive for collaboration. However, to make engineering organization to use these tools is not a simple task. I want to bring 3 main roadblocks. In my view, most of cloud collaboration tools ignored them in their initial and sometimes even second incarnation.

1- The ease of data upload.

What is good for photo, doesn’t work well for engineers and CAD tools. Photo is all about how to upload a single file or a folder with bunch of photos from your last vacation. CAD design contains multiple files often located in several folders with references on standard parts, etc. File/Upload function doesn’t fit here.

2- Organizational security and data access.

Every organization, even small engineering firm is taking care about file access. Integration with directory service such as LDAP is probably “must have”. However, very often, access rules can go even future and integrate with security access of existing applications – PDM/PLM, ERP, CRM, etc.

3- Integration with desktop tools.

Integration inside CAD (and other desktop tools) can help people to start sharing data easier. As soon as you come close to basic PDM function of revision management, integration with desktop tool is must. To integrated with desktop tool is not simple. Many cloud collaboration tools are ignoring it from the beginning.

What is my conclusion?  Cloud collaboration tools are going through the difficult time of maturity. The time when website allowed to everyone to upload CAD file(s) for free and watch it on iPad is over. To remove organizational roadblocks preventing engineers to use tool broadly in an organization as well as to provide interesting capabilities to collaborate efficiently is more important. Just my thoughts…

Best, Oleg

Share

Share This Post

  • Your are dead right that cloud collaboration tools ignore the desktop – there’s a reason they do, because they are trying to push authoring activities as SaaS. That’s what Google Docs does. While that might work to a limited extent for simple documents, it breaks down entirely with CAD, you need the authoring application!

    And when it comes to assembly structure, that’s an alien concept for the collaboration companies most of whom have a decidedly non-engineering background. GrabCAD’s the only one in the collab space that understands CAD product structure.

  • beyondplm

    Ed, I think companies developing cloud collaboration are afraid to loose differentiation factors in terms of cloud vs. desktop tools and therefore trying not to support desktop. It is obviously creates a better position for cloud authoring tools.

  • Pingback: Ways On How You Can Use Your Ipad Effectively | The Cheap iPad Store()

  • Pingback: IPad Help And Hints To Maximize Your Experience | The Cheap iPad Store()