A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

PLM vs Excel: Bullfight and Prohibition

PLM vs Excel: Bullfight and Prohibition
Oleg
Oleg
27 July, 2015 | 2 min for reading

plm-spreadsheet-bull-fight

PLM has love and hate relationships with Excel spreadsheets. PLM vendors are spending marketing dollars campaigning to replace Excel. The last post by Lionel Grealou caught my attention during the weekend. Navigate to read PLM vs Excel post here. In addition to to almost traditional confirmation that PLM can outperform Excel spreadsheet, I noticed an interesting statement about the fact some organizations are prohibiting availability of Excel reports. This is a passage I captured:

Some organizations considered removing access to import from / export to Excel from their PLM applications to limit uncontrolled usage of data and reports. Most PLM applications now have advanced data search, live feed dashboard which can be tailored to business needs, with Excel-like features for data mining, profiling, compiling, formatting, presenting in various chart for analysis.

The comparison of PLM vs Excel capabilities for BOM management looks like a bullfight. But honestly, I’m not sure who is who in this fight. PLM vendors are fighting excel spreadsheets for decades with no visible success. The number of whitepapers and sales materials trying to convince users how much damage Excel can do is skyrocketing. But customers are still using Excel.

To remove an access to Excel reports is actually something new and unexpected. I had a chance to see many situations when IT was developed bunch of Excel-based solutions to eliminate the need of end users to touch complex enterprise systems in manufacturing, supply chain and finance. Customers loved Excel and hate complex enterprise software. Which reminded me my very old blog – Why do I like my PLM Excel Spreadsheets with top 5 reasons why I prefer Excel over PLM system. To balance a PLM point of view, I can recommend another post – What PLM need to take over Excel spreadsheets?

What is my conclusion? I’m sure you know that bulls are colorblind. Matadors used red material to mask the bull’s blood. PLM sales materials explaining the value of PLM systems vs Excel spreadsheets is like read caps. Users seems to me colorblind to recognize them. Prohibition also seems to me as a bad way to convince users. Especially in our era of consumerization and total focus on user experience. Enterprise UX is going through the paradigm shift. Old, bulky, cumbersome, weighty and hard to use environment that can block a productive flow will be replaced with new tools. It is all about the need for speed. When each function engineers need is “15 clicks away”, you cannot expect company to perform well. Just my thoughts…

Best, Oleg

Image courtesy of vectorolie at FreeDigitalPhotos.net

 

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
21 May, 2019

It is a time to come back to Open Source software discussion. Open source was not the hottest buzzword for...

15 June, 2010

I had chance to read “SAP, Oracle and ‘Real’ Real-Time Apps“. I think it is an interesting read. SAP and...

13 October, 2009

First of all, I’m sorry about such a topic. Yes, Usability! I think we have been talking about usability for...

18 May, 2013

PLM and ERP integration is not a new topic. Step in the discussion about any PLM implementation and you will...

4 February, 2019

Complexity of PLM systems and user experience is well-known problem in the world of PLM. Even all PLM vendors are...

8 January, 2014

There is no person in manufacturing universe that can underestimate the importance of right Bill of Material information. However, I...

5 March, 2010

I had the chance to read Jim Brown’s post about SAP achievements in PLM. As usual, when PLM and ERP...

17 July, 2011

What is the most popular PDM/PLM system in the world? My bet it is probably MS Excel. The flexibility and...

30 July, 2012

For many people PLM is associated with Engineering. At the same time, it is not true. Very often, major portion of...

Blogroll

To the top