A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

Faltered Licenses and Future PLM Business Models

Faltered Licenses and Future PLM Business Models
olegshilovitsky
olegshilovitsky
3 February, 2010 | 3 min for reading

In my view, we are observing the major disruption of enterprise software business models ever. Since yesterday’s post FREE and COOL trends in CAD/PLM I had chance to have quite many discussions with my colleagues about possible new innovative business models in product lifecycle management. I have to say, that COOL option seems something that considered as simpler one. However, FREE option is something that raising many interesting questions and opinions. In my view, the most powerful business models need to be dumb simple. Let think about that. The PLM business fundamental, as a typical enterprise business today is presented by ability to sell licenses, maintenance and services.

Licenses. These are the basics of enterprise software business – expensive licenses and focus on the business value proposition. This model worked well for many years. This is still the most used business model in the enterprises.

Maintenance. In my view, this is the first source of revenues for enterprise software vendors in the bad economy. It is obviously depending on how your customers hold back against recession, but maintenance revenues is definite pain relief for many vendors these days.

Services. The ultimate way to customize your product and support all customer needs. The relative weight of services in each industry shows, in my view, the maturity of products and adoption level for mainstream deployment.

Before talking about the possible options, I want to bring some very interesting article in UK’s Independent. You can see it here. Oracle is suing small rival providing services for Oracle customers. Without going in details, my hunch is that services become a more important component of enterprise business. Similar to what happens with IBM when they were enforced by Microsoft to re-build their business around services, we can see similar signals in the current enterprise business outfits.

So, what are possible directions in the future business models I can see?

Subscription Models
In my view, the most straightforward. You are not paying for licenses, but pay for subscriptions. The obvious advantages are to simplify user adoption and decrease upfront cost for customers. On the dark side of this model is customer’s feeling to “pay for bug fixing”, which moves customer satisfaction level down. This model is actively discovered by providers of Open Source and Free Software providers.

Reverse Models
This is something that can really improve the subscription model. Let’s make subscription model to work in reverse. In this case, customer will pay a subscription fee if software works. What will happen in case of problems? Yes, customer stops paying. Does it sound weird? Maybe, but I found similar models are working in different industries like, for example, in medical services in China.

Advertising Models
This is the most fascinating one. I think, relationships between advertising and enterprise need to be researched from the beginning in 2000s. There are several factors that will drive the future change in this space: cloud applications, subscriptions and online business. My hunch is that advertising money can be turned toward payment for enterprise software vendors and PLM’s unique potential, here is in the ability to manage complete product information including interaction with customers and suppliers during the whole product lifecycle. Yes, to prevent some comments – it may not work for all industries. However, industries like consumer products, telecommunications, high-tech, apparel has a huge potential to use it in the future.

So, what is my conclusion today? We are going to see continues disruption of enterprise software business soon. These are my thoughts. Does it make sense to you? I’m looking forward to our future discussion.

Best, Oleg

Share

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
12 July, 2010

PLM is certainly dealing with lots of data about products: design, engineering, lifecycle data, manufacturing, processes. When/If you speak to...

11 February, 2024

Earlier this weekend I read a sad news about passing of John Walker, the founder and the father of AutoCAD...

8 February, 2021

My recent blog about how to integrate BOMs and also the opportunity to have a Single BOM? brought many questions...

28 January, 2015

Cloud is trending and it is hard to find a company who is not thinking how to leverage new cloud...

18 February, 2017

Have you heard about Platformization and Product Innovation Platforms? Platformization is a new trend that was outlined by several industry analysts...

28 May, 2022

Data is a very fascinating word. A few weeks ago, I was invited by Nina Dar to her Change Troubleshooter...

17 July, 2009

I’m thinking, how PLM can become leaner and efficient. In today’s economical situation and even in general, to make PLM...

9 October, 2015

I’ve been on the road for the last few days. It occurred to me that I hardly imagine my travel...

17 February, 2025

For the past 20 years, the smartphone has revolutionized the way we live, work, and communicate. It is an incredibly...

Blogroll

To the top