A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

PDM weakest link

PDM weakest link
Oleg
Oleg
8 July, 2014 | 3 min for reading

cad-file-transfer

You’re only as strong as your weakest link. The article Are You Still Using FTP for CAD File Transfer? on Engineering.com by Scott Wertel caught my attention few days ago. The article compares FTP, cloud file sharing and cloud based PDM. Read the article and draw your opinion. I found something  common between all these approaches – you need to transfer files between desktop or LAN server and some other (usually remote) locations – FTP, virtual cloud drive or similar storage used by cloud PDM. Here is my favorite passage:

Let’s look at a product development scenario.  A designer has finished the preliminary design of a brand new widget.  He is in a small design shop, so he keeps the files on his personal computer. He wants a rapid prototype of the design made so he emails the file to a service bureau.  As the bureau is working up a quote for the prototype, the designer notices a few things and makes some tweaks.  The file size is too big now, so he uploads it to his company’s FTP site and emails a notification to the bureau.  But, because the project is still in development and no files have been released, the designer doesn’t change the revision on the file.  It’s the same filename on the FTP site as was emailed previously to the service bureau. Now the bureau has two files downloaded to their system.  Both with the same filename and both contain relatively the same time stamp caused by saving the email attachment at about the same time they downloaded the file from the FTP site.  Rather than being able to quickly quote the part and begin shooting laser beams, they have to spend the time to reconcile the files, also taking up the designer’s time.

So, in my view, the need to send files between local computer and remote location is the weakest link to make that work efficient. Both PDM and any other file sharing service will face this challenge. And, forget the cloud and internet for a minute) it was the same challenge back in every PDM system developed in the past. PDM developers used different techniques to optimize file transfer, but the problem remains the same – slow connection and large files.

The move to the cloud, actually, doesn’t change much. The connection is still slow (relatively) and files are still big (or even getting bigger). As I discussed few days ago in my How to move CAD files  to the cloud post, a special technology needed that will break CAD files synchronization process and make the process transparent. At the same time, user should be able to work on the same file to satisfy the scenario described in the beginning of this post. Whoever will be able to accomplish so, will take a huge advantage of knowledge about CAD files and improved user experience. Read more here – CAD companies and cloud storage strategy.

What is my conclusion? The weakest link of PDM is the ability to sync large multi-file design between local discs and cloud (server) storage. It was the problem back to PDM development in 1990s and it remains the problem today. Until now, cloud doesn’t change much, since most of  cloud PDM and file-share vendors are taking CAD files with existing boundaries. To break these boundaries and develop technology to move file efficiently while allowing to user to work on the same files at the same time, can be a deal breaker and huge step to fix the weakest link. Just my thoughts…

Best, Oleg

 

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
10 March, 2011

Virtualization becomes an important piece of modern technological solutions. The time of physical servers is over. Businesses are actively seeking...

18 June, 2019

Unless you’ve been living under the rock for the last decade, you’ve heard about open source software, hardware or anything...

15 March, 2016

Innovation platform is a new name in the competition of PLM and engineering software. The message is widely supported by analysts...

7 October, 2012

Two weeks ago, I published a provoking blog post proposing to stop “Engineering PLM”. Quite many people responded – the...

15 February, 2020

3DEXPERIENCE platform brings a few new product names and 3DEXPERIENCE World 2020 was a good opportunity to learn more about...

8 September, 2009

I want to touch today topic related to user experience in various PLM systems. Having such powerful function as 3D...

30 March, 2010

Thanks for one of my readers who sent me the link to Wrench Enterprise. Their presentation about project collaboration and...

3 December, 2022

PLM adoption is hard. The history of PLM projects start as engineering projects and, unfortunately, struggles with many aspects related...

4 July, 2016

Timing is everything. When you want to develop a new service or change an existing one, time criteria is crucial....

Blogroll

To the top