A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

Why PLM platform need to support inefficient organizational rituals?

Why PLM platform need to support inefficient organizational rituals?
Oleg
Oleg
3 November, 2016 | 2 min for reading

plm-rituals-organization-change

Change management and PLM implementations are hard. You can check some of my earlier blogs to catch up on the topic.  – PLM implementation and organizational change and PLM and death spiral of cultural change. I also recommend you to check Jos Voksuil’s articles – Our brain blocks PLM acceptance and PLM and blockers. Organizational change is part of business process improvement and it can turn PLM projects into a complete nightmare.

I’ve been catching up on news and read articles during my flight to Detroit to attend CIMdata PLM roadmap for automotive and supply chain. The following article – Why getting rid of inefficient processes in the organization is so hard. Anthropology explains it by Leonardo Herrero – Architect of Organizations caught my special attention.

So, according to Leonardo Herrero, anthropology can easy explain everything that happens in an organization when it comes to process improvement. Here is catch 22…

Most inefficient processes that stay in place in defiance of logic, and that seem to be resistant to modification, may be so stable because they are very effective. At something else, that is. Their efficiency as processes may be low and frustrating, but they may be very effective as rituals.

It made me think that PLM implementations are typically coming to organizations as process improvement and completely missing the ritual thing. And it can put organization in a death spiral of changes, because it will try to remove organizational alpha-male and alpha-female space for rituals, with the programmable logic of PLM workflows.

In ritual terms, that needs time and space. In process-efficiency times, you could cut the whole thing easily by 50%. But if you did, you would eliminate part of the glue: people defending positions, playing their personal power-capital, testing each other, protecting the turf, enjoying deep and rational discussions (‘hard work’), establishing alliances, protecting against the enemy, performing, including some, excluding others, etc. And suppressing these would be a big problem in the absence of another platform in which all those games of power and inclusiveness could take place. Eliminating the campfire without an alternative does not sound as a good idea.

What is my conclusion? PLM strategist and architects should think how to bring a replacement to inefficient process rituals. There is a lot of things we can learn from social network experience of the last decade. In my view, the success of some social networks is directly related to support of some fundamental social rituals. So we should do for future PLM platforms. Just my thoughts…

Best, Oleg

Want to learn more about PLM? Check out my new PLM Book website.

Disclaimer: I’m co-founder and CEO of openBoM developing cloud based bill of materials and inventory management tool for manufacturing companies, hardware startups and supply chain. My opinion can be unintentionally biased.

 

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
22 October, 2013

PLM for small companies is long time debated topic. The origins of PLM business are going deep into businesses of...

7 August, 2013

Recent debate on Tech4PD brought back one of my favorite topics in PLM – data vs. process. The topic isn’t...

17 August, 2021

Businesses must constantly plan for the future. In the world of manufacturing companies, the future is now. How to get...

3 September, 2010

Manufacturers are going global these days. Nobody is surprised to have design, manufacturing and support are going across the globe....

8 October, 2009

Do you remember, PLM Think Tank is about future crazy ideas? So, here you go – one that I liked...

10 April, 2013

I’ve been attending North American PLM Market & Industry Forum organized by CIMdata earlier today. CIMdata is running these forums...

4 April, 2021

Data is everywhere these days and I see more and more people taking data seriously when it comes to the...

1 May, 2019

Every CAD system is using so-called geometric modeling kernel – 3D modeling component. If you want to know what 3D...

11 July, 2012

Let’s talk today about databases and database technologies. Everybody these days understands what is that… Database technology became an essential...

Blogroll

To the top