PLM and MDM – How to start right?

Product Lifecycle Management and Master Data Management. I had chance to raise this issue few months ago in my post Will Master Data Management Work for PLM? Few days ago, interesting publication from Gartner about their research in area of MDM and, more specifically, about overlap between MDM and PLM. Andrew White together with Marc Halpern published paper called “Interfacing of PLM and MDM for cross enterprise needs”. The conclusion made by Andrew in his blog article is simple – use a right tool for the right job.
In more detailed way, they explained PLM itself as a not mature software category in comparison to ERP, SCM, CRM etc. With lack of maturity and unclear agreed position and usage of MDM, PDM, PLM prevented earlier exploration of intersection between these domains.

gartner-mdm-white

Now, I’d like to come back to my initial question – how to start right? What is my concern about approach “right tool for right job”? As soon as we speak about corporate and enterprise data and product IP/Knowledge, I think this approach may not work. Today’s enterprise is very siloed, information span across multiple systems – engineering, manufacturing, procurement, supply chain. As soon as a system identify in the particular functional domain, it will not create major conflicts. I see relatively simple approach to position PDM as a system to manage design and engineering data only together with Master Data Management. However, when we come to PLM approach, I see definitely conflict of interest. In my view PLM and MDM strategy has similarity in their approaches to create “single point of truth” in organization.

So, what I see as a possible PLM/MDM strategy? I think, MDM strategy and infrastructure, can provide possible foundation for managing of non-transactional data for product development. This data can be accumulated by MDM and saved for future usage. Today’s PLM implementations are mostly focused around product development, so such MDM infrastructure can be good asset PLM can use to achieve long term data retention and other data management needs. At the same time, such approach can bring significant investment into both PLM and MDM systems and probably can be acceptable only by large enterprises.

I’m interested in discussion, if you had any experience with MDM and PLM system co-existence.
Best regards,
Oleg

Share

Share This Post

  • In my opinion, PLM systems are (or at least are designed to be) a specialized MDM system for product information. There is much more to a company that its product information, and PLM is not designed to manage all that. But the intellectual property contained in product information is the true richness of a manufacturing company.

    Managing product information is not an abstract goal, which PLM vendors try to achieve without ever getting close, it’s daily life of our customers: if only I had a dollar for each time I heard “if it’s not in PLM, it doesn’t exist”…

    Moreover, PLM is more than a reference database, it is a collaborative process centric environment that guides the development and the evolution of a consistent and quality assured reference set of product information (which evolves rapidly and needs process control to ensure quality of the end result); this process centricity sometimes took the limelight from the purpose of PLM as product information reference base. Nevertheless, product information from PLM is used in many downstream processes: as the maturity of the PLM system grows, so integrations with other systems increase in number and complexity, starting from ERP in Materials management, but not limited to that.

    This requires an appropriate strategy from the PLM vendors, focused on openness. Openness means providing both the tools to access PLM information (SOA layers, EAI applications …) and a clear strategy to publish this information (available data models, flexible and understood export and import protocols).

  • Hello Paolo, You made very interesting definition of PLM as a specialized MDM system. I never heard such definition before. In my view, the core reason for MDM system (if I’d think about such a system in organization) would be to have a **single** master data management system. How do you see such multiple master systems in the organization? Another question I have is related to your comment about ability of PLM system to manage product information without even getting close… Do you think MDM can be possible solution for organization? What is PMI system role? According to the Gartner, PMI is part of MDM…
    Thank you for your comments and welcome to plmtwine discussion! Best, Oleg

  • Awadhesh Parihar

    My take is, the discussion is as fundamental as what is the difference between MDM and Database Management System, than MDM to PLM or ERP.

    All database management systems can aspire to be more than just managing data, but to also orechestrate the business processes which create or use the data. But, I believe technology has evolved in various dimensions since this debate would have started, and niches were created

    PLM/PDM systems, have one more level of complexity as opposed to storing data and managing business processes/decisions, as compared to transactional systems, and thats of enabling iterations so typical of engineering design, development and sustenance. If one is keen on seeing it this way, they would think of serializing all CAX information and put them in database.

    Amount of data that resides in CAX artifacts (read design and analysis data), and intellectual property differentiators to a company thereby, PLM systems are closest to understanding and alleviating the complexity involved, than MDM or Oracle databases

    Long ago, during my formative years, someone told me what a PLM system is – just a database, a UI and a middle layer. I kept thinking since then, if mammoth of an SAP system, is not the same 🙂 or for that matter all MIS systems. That over simplification helps but doesnt get the job done

  • Awadhesh, Great thoughts. I like your associations and analyzes related to DM, MDM and business systems like PLM/ERP. The difference between DM/MDM and business systems are first in their ability to keep data consistency related to business logic (whatever, CAX IP or ERP transactions). Data Management solutions are only taking care of data schema. No business logic involved. This is the current state of the art in this domain. However, future may be different. The ideas of MDM related to data modeling and scalability can be beneficial for PLM, especially in case, when MDM brings the ability to change/transform master data easily. Best, Oleg

  • My spouse and I absolutely love your blog and find almost all of your post’s to be precisely what I’m looking for.
    Do you offer guest writers to write content for you?
    I wouldn’t mind composing a post or elaborating on a few of the subjects you
    write regarding here. Again, awesome blog!

  • These are truly wonderful ideas in concerning blogging.
    You have touched some fastidious points here. Any way keep up wrinting.

  • I’ve seen some pretty happy kids bounding into the store, needing to redeem a
    gift card they received within their stocking. But with all thhe a
    solid release date for Mass Effect 2, at the very least we have something
    to look for in the first month of next year.
    Many small businesses often provide gift certificates to local Lions Clubs,
    Rotary Clubs and other civic organizations
    to use for raffles along with other fundraising events.

  • This is the perfect webpage for anybody who hopes to find
    out about this topic. You understand so much its almost
    hard to argue with you (not that I personally would want to…HaHa).
    You certainly put a new spin on a subject that’s been written about for a long time.
    Wonderful stuff, just wonderful!

  • I am regular visitor, how are you everybody? This paragraph posted
    at this web site is actually fastidious.