A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

Why Social PLM 1.0 Failed?

Why Social PLM 1.0 Failed?
Oleg
Oleg
7 January, 2013 | 3 min for reading

What do you think about “social PLM” trend? I don’t see many cheerleaders of social PLM nowadays. The excitement and social PLM fluff is over. Some of these companies turned into boring “collaborating utilities” with a flavor or enterprise security. Some of companies produced good “facebook user experience clones” and got acquired by enterprise vendors. Overall, “social” didn’t created a revolution in PLM. So, it is a good time to think about what happened and learn lessons for the future.

I’ve been reading A VC blog by Fred Willson of Union Ventures. Read this short article – Single User Utility In A Social System. The conclusion of Fred about single utility resonated. Fred brings “delicious example”, which is very good in my view. Here is my favorite passage:

One of the most important lessons we took from delicious was the value of single user utility in social systems. It might seem odd that systems designed to leverage interactions between people can have (should have?) single person utility. But I strongly believe they should. The first users of delicious were barely aware of and rarely used its social aspects. They just wanted to store their bookmarks in the cloud instead of in their browser. And they liked the tag based classification system. And they liked being able to use their links from any device. That was the single person utility delicious was built on. But because bookmarks were public by default which resulted in most links being shared with others, a large social system developed. The delicious popular page was an important web destination in its day and most of those visitors never posted a link to delicious. They consumed others’ links.

I’d bring few additional examples. First – photo sharing websites. Most of them started as a place for photographers to keep their photos and only after added an additional function of sharing photos. Another one – GPS navigation, which originally single utility function. Then we can see “social navigation” system like Waze created social value beyond this single function.

Social PLM focus on “collaboration” was a right one. However, it missed a single function that can provide an ultimate value to a single user. What is that function? I can speculate it is the ability to share and manage data supplied be a single user. Similar to photo websites and later to many other Web 2.0 sites, a single content creation and management function was missed. With more systems moving to cloud today, we have a chance to fix this problem.

What is my conclusion? When it comes to enterprise software, value proposition is a key element in a sales process. Nothing wrong here. However, it was a point where “social PLM 1.0” activities failed. Most of social PLM products and initiatives were too focused on company value proposition and missed a single “user function” that can make them useful for people in a company first. However, you cannot stop people from innovation. Next wave of social initiatives is coming and it won’t miss single user function to make it successful.

Best, Oleg

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
20 July, 2015

We speak about new technological trends and how to simplify enterprise implementation. At the same time, large CAD and PLM...

7 December, 2011

Back to the beginning of this year, I came with the post – Integrating PLM and PDM. Wrong question? My...

22 May, 2009

Look on this blog post –3D Warehouse from Google. Does it make sense in context of what CAD/PLM vendors are...

10 January, 2014

Management of product data was always a first and most important imperative for PLM solutions. Depends on vendor strategy and...

27 November, 2011

The announcement made by Dassault System last week, made me think about a huge distance CAD industry passed for the...

7 April, 2010

I had chance to read The Practice of Global Product Development at MIT Sloan Management Review. You can find  the...

3 February, 2025

Have you ever tried to eat an apple but only managed to finish half? It’s still better than not having...

6 September, 2013

My father was engineer. As a child, I’ve been coming to my dad’s office to watch how engineers designed metallurgical...

29 February, 2016

Part Number is a fundamental element of any identification mechanism in product development and manufacturing. The debates about intelligent and...

Blogroll

To the top