A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

Two decades of PLM SMB innovation and next steps

Two decades of PLM SMB innovation and next steps
Oleg
Oleg
8 August, 2018 | 3 min for reading

One of the readers of my blog, raised the topic of PLM for SMB. Long time ago I was working at SmarTeam developing PDM and PLM solutions for mid-sized manufacturing companies. The following passage reminded me discussion about PLM for SMB that happened in the industry for almost 2 decades.

In a world where companies do not want to pay the massive price tag to bring on a legacy PLM tool (especially in the SMB space), SaaS/Multi-tenant is the only way to go.  The PLM market has been slow to adopt it, but it NEEDS to and will come shortly 😉

PLM for SMB is an old topic. But it seems to be still relevant and PLM companies are still not resolved the problem.  You can find few good articles written by Jos Voskuil about PLM for SMB. My favorite is this one. What if SMB as a vision for PLM and PLM vendors don’t understand it. You can find some of my relatively recent articles about PLM for SMB – Is it a time to change PLM for SMB mantra and call it “efficient PLM”?

Long time ago, PLM was designed to serve large organization with their data and change management processes. PLM systems were big, complex and requires lot of effort to make it work.  As PLM companies progressed in the market the question how to address problems of different organization (and not only large OEMs) became important. PLM vendors used different approaches and marketed them differently. I captured them below in the following diagram.

Recent development of SaaS application is certainly addressing some of the problems associated with smaller manufacturing companies

1. IT Resources

2. Expensive licensing model

3. Complex user experience

These are absolutely valid points, but in my view, root cause of PLM for SMB failures aren’t exactly about cost and resources. In my view, it is related to effort / ROI balance of current PLM implementation paradigm. This paradigm is focusing on a specific organizational behaviors (mostly controlling data). It works well and for the last decade we can see an increased adoption of simpler PDM systems. However, when it comes to expanding PLM outside of engineering, the adoption is slowing down and %% of smaller organization ready to accept the solution is much lower. So, conceptually PLM barrier is too high.  At the same time, PLM isn’t addressing easy enough collaboration and communication between different organization, downstream information availability and online internet experience (this is why modern PLM companies are brining the topic of multi-tenancy).

What is my conclusion? I think for many manufacturing companies PLM is a long term vision that never materialized. I can see how PLM concepts were pushed in different forms to small organization but there is a need for a different solution. Cloud is a starting point. Enabler. But, paradigm shift is required. Single point of truth isn’t good in the environment where many companies contractors and individuals are working together. Simplification and network experience can make a difference. I think small is a new big and “SMB” tag is really annoying innovative people running agile business these days. Just my thoughts…

Best, Oleg

Want to learn more about PLM? Check out my new PLM Book website.

Disclaimer: I’m co-founder and CEO of OpenBOM developing cloud based bill of materials and inventory management tool for manufacturing companies, hardware startups and supply chain. My opinion can be unintentionally biased.

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
16 October, 2019

It has been seven years since Autodesk introduced Fusion 360. I checked my old blog – What Fusion 360 means...

10 July, 2013

Mobile development is skyrocketing these days. Everybody wants to be mobile. Enterprise vendors slowly discovering the power of mobile apps....

11 February, 2011

Today everything can be virtualized. If you think about your dedicated IT environment, proprietary or public cloud, the ability to...

13 September, 2010

Last week I published my visual guide how to choose PLM. This post was the most popular during the whole...

26 August, 2011

PLM 2.0 is a new term that was born about 5 years ago. The term was introduced by Dassault Sysetemes...

25 June, 2010

When you talk to a sales person from one of the PLM companies, you for sure will be exposed to...

8 June, 2016

I’m attending PTC LiveWox 2016 event these days in Boston. An impressive gathering of ~4000 people sharing and learning about...

30 December, 2015

Standards are similar toothbrushes. Everyone need one, but nobody wants to somebody else standard. CAD and PLM solutions are supporting...

11 June, 2015

  Version control is one of the most important function in PDM. Regardless on what type of data you are managing,...

Blogroll

To the top