A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

PLM Complexity: What Does The Future Hold?

PLM Complexity: What Does The Future Hold?
Oleg
Oleg
21 March, 2011 | 2 min for reading

One of my blog readers shared with me slides of Paul Saunders presentation about MRO software from the Miami Aircraft Commerce Aviation IT Conference March 2011. I found the presentation very timely. Author is focusing on MRO systems and makes analyzes about why MRO systems are so complicated and who is responsible for such a situation. In addition to that Paul made some prediction about the future of MRO systems as well as some software development trends. Despite the fairly significant size (110 slides), I recommend you to spend some time and go through the slides. Do it and make your opinion?

This presentation made me think again about PLM complexity. About a year ago, I wrote about PLM and Collapse of Complex Societies. Following the Tainter’s theory, PLM system just created another level of bureaucracy. What are the sources of bureaucracy and why complex PLM systems are following these rules?

Sources of Complexity

The fundamental intent of Product Lifecycle Management is to organize a product development processes. It implies lots of assumptions about what is the process? how data is organized? how people are interacting? what are organizational boundaries and other business processes? PLM system development followed the set of rules developed by predecessors in enterprise software and mostly MRP and ERP systems. Software vendors built the top down system organization and tried to formalize organizational data and processes. However, product development process diversity between manufacturing companies made this formalization process impossible. Development created multiple “options” and predefined schemas. When it came to the implementation, it resulted in a huge amount of customization and system tailoring. In addition to that, companies were concerned about the competition.

The Future is Open?

Play with openness and data in enterprise organizations was probably the most dangerous and destructive for end users. As I wrote in my post – The Ugly Truth about PLM-ERP Monkey Volleyball, enterprise software companies are trying to control data and, as a result, limiting availability and access to this data from other vendors. The openness creates a situation when a company will be able to choose a better tool without sniffing around the existing tool. The biggest lesson PLM and other enterprise software need to learn is how to switch towards open data, open systems and open architecture.

What is my conclusion? The following sentence from Paul’s slides is a key: this software isn’t complex enough. Have you had a chance to hear it for the last week, month, year? No. Vendors need to fight complexity in PLM products. The first things to target is a system openness and a complexity of user experience. The complexity game is over. Finally…

Best, Oleg

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
16 October, 2014

It has been more than two years since I was reviewing Kenesto – an outfit founded by Mike Payne with...

13 February, 2018

How to build reliable PLM system? For long time, this topic is among the most often demanded requirement in engineering...

7 August, 2009

Dear Friends, Don’t worry, everything is okay with PLM Think Tank. This short notice is to inform that I’m going...

9 September, 2016

Software is eating the world. Unless you’ve been living under the rock for the last few years, you know what...

23 May, 2013

Office and other productivity tools are un-separateable parts of product development environment. Some of them such Microsoft Excel literally can...

4 May, 2012

I want to come back to the topic that drives more of my interest lately – BIM and PLM. In...

19 March, 2010

I was watching Mentor Graphics presentation yesterday about their Valor acquisition. If you haven’t had a chance to watch it,...

27 June, 2014

For me, Google is one of the symbols of simple software design. Therefore, Google developers event is always a good...

18 June, 2022

I’ve been following Autodesk PLM development for the last decade. It has many turns during that time- from ignoring PLM...

Blogroll

To the top