A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

Multi-CAD and PDM: Dead Lock?

Multi-CAD and PDM: Dead Lock?
Oleg
Oleg
17 February, 2012 | 2 min for reading

This post was provoked by twitter conversation between me, Jonathan Scott of Razorleaf and Brian Roepke of Autodesk. Let me give you a context. During SolidWorks World general session yesterday, Jonathan commented about coming SolidWorks EPDM integration with DraftSight – free CAD software for your DWG files.  I thought, it might be beneficial to have DraftSight integration with Autodesk Vault. However, it appears to be a mistake. Watch that…

This conversation made me think again about what happens in the space of integration of product data management products and design software. Time ago, I posted – Immersive CAD management: is it the CAD / PDM future? Another post related to the same topic was – Back to basics: Multi-CAD and PLM. Last year, I posted CAD, PDM and PLM diversity. What I found common between all these cases is that I can see more and more stable bundles between CAD and PDM systems.

I can see an increased demand for better data-management functionality in CAD systems. The integration of data-management applications increased over the past 2-3 years. Vendors started to think about PDM functionality like revision management and vaulting as a standard function in CAD applications. Dassault V6 took this process even future and introduced CATIA V6 bundled with ENOVIA server.

In my view, CAD-PDM integration played a significant role in the first wave of broad PDM adoption. Multi-CAD support was (and still is) considered as an important function of PDM (and sometimes even PLM) system. To support heterogeneous environment, pure play PDM/PLM vendors must include multi-CAD support. It happened almost to all vendors in PDM/PLM space. On the opposite side, CAD/PDM vendors decided to strength their bundles and prefer to integrate data-management systems only with their own CAD systems. In my view, Multi-CAD integration is a painful issue for pure-play PDM/PLM vendors like Arena, Aras and future others. The complexity of CAD integration with PDM and PLM systems create a significant competitive advantage for CAD vendors to bundle their own PDMs right. At the same time, PDM providers from CAD vendors are less interested to provide support for “non-home-based” CAD systems.

What is my conclusion? I can see a certain dead-lock between the need for multi-CAD PDM systems and interest of CAD/PDM vendors to protect their business. Customers are demanding PDM systems like TeamCenter, Autodesk Vault, SolidWorks EPDM to support Multi-CAD features. However, it looks more and more like a dead-lock. PDM system will be embedded into CAD environment and will become part of the whole design environment. It doesn’t mean new innovative companies won’t try to break this dead-lock. Just my thoughts…

Best, Oleg

[Update]. I keep open conversation with participants of this tweet-chat. You can expect some updates about the topic very soon.

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
7 October, 2013

The life of IT departments is complicated these days. What was IT kingdom 10 years ago gone forever. IT is...

24 May, 2017

PLM definition is one of these questions that often come in the discussions between industry analysts, bloggers and PLM pundits. While...

22 September, 2015

For the last decade, many industries learned lesson or two about disruption and how internet and other technologies can change...

22 January, 2019

Once upon a time, PLM and cloud things were not friends. PLM companies were telling that cloud is not secured...

28 October, 2014

  Few months ago, I posted about potential for Apple and IBM to open a door for mobile PLM future....

9 July, 2010

The problem of CAD file conversion in old and has never been easy. Engineers are working in multiple CAD systems...

7 September, 2020

I had a chance to dig into The State of Product Development 2020 report done by Onshape. You can get...

29 July, 2009

Thinking in loud. I’m looking over many user interfaces of PLM systems and reading “Don’t make me think“. Why every...

30 December, 2013

End of the year is traditionally associated with “top stories” and “next year predictions”. So, it is hard to resist…...

Blogroll

To the top