A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

Will CFO like “cloud PLM”?

Will CFO like “cloud PLM”?
Oleg
Oleg
12 April, 2012 | 2 min for reading

Cost is one of the aspects all cloud PLM providers bring to the table these days. The demand and the expection is that that PLM (or any other software) on the cloud will become cheaper than on-premises’ alternative.

Earlier this week, I’ve been reading an article from CIO magazine – Why CFO and Cloud Computing Have a Love-Hate Relationships. The article is worth reading. Author is talking about different aspects on how CFO in a company perceive advantages and disadvantages of cloud solutions. According to the author, there is no confirmation about cost-competitiveness of AWS. Here is an interesting passage, in my view:

The author evaluated the historical price changes in AWS S3 storage vs. on-premises, disk-based storage and concluded that AWS isn’t cost competitive. Moreover, he asserted that AWS storage isn’t realizing (or at least, isn’t passing on) the benefits of Moore’s Law, since its prices aren’t dropping as rapidly as on-premises storage pricing.

Later in the article author discussing “love” and “hate” aspects of cloud computing from the standpoint of CFO. The basis of resource consumption is related to the most “hated” behavior. On the side of “love” is clearly the ability of the cloud to turn your company capital investment into something that will be considered as “pay-as-you-go-service”.

I wanted to bring some examples of Cloud PLM cost. Today, I can see it mostly around two companies and products – Arena Solutions and Autodesk PLM 360. Arena is a long-time player for OnDemand, SaaS and cloud PLM. It wasn’t simple to find pricing page for Arena PLM on their website. Finally, I found it. Here is the link. You can start with Arena at 79 per-user per-month. In addition to that you have a menu to get a quote.

At the end of the last year I took my first attempt to discuss it. Navigate to my post – PLM, Cost and Enterprisey Clouds. The example of PLM cloud deployment for 200 people presented at AU2012 stated 10x difference between so-called “Traditional PLM” and Autodesk.

The new version presented during Autodesk Media Summit two weeks ago presented even bigger distance between traditional PLM and Cloud PLM.

What is my conclusion? The best interest of cloud providers is to set up and an aggressive pricing strategy. As we all know from the public web, the usage is the first important thing towards winning a competition battle online. In my view, actual usage is clearly missed today for Autodesk PLM 360. Arena is probably operating with some historical examples, but I have never seen them published. I also don’t expect vendors to share cost structure publicly. The absence of examples and pricing reflecting “consumption rates” for storage or computing resources hints to the fact that cloud PLM is still far from maturity. So, I can see everything that happens now as very interesting and promising experiments that clearly can make CFO happy in the cloudy PLM future. The jury is still out…

Best, Oleg

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
4 September, 2015

Just to think about integrations and PLM can hurt your mind. Integrations are complex and expensive business. It is not...

23 June, 2014

One day you discover that your PLM implementation project is not doing so well. It happens and it called failure....

10 September, 2010

I’m going to join this first COFES Russia event on 21th September. Earlier this week David Levin of LEDAS announced his vision...

4 November, 2013

Transformation of business models is one of the most important trends that happens today in the industry. Take a deep...

22 February, 2017

Digitalization is the integration of digital technologies into engineering and manufacturing process by switching from traditional process into a new...

20 August, 2010

The following publication in VEKTORRUM got me to review again a book “3D Manufacturing Innovation” by Dr. Hiroshi Toriya. I...

19 November, 2019

I’m attending Autodesk University 2019 in Las Vegas. If you never been at AU, this is an annual extravaganza of...

14 December, 2015

CAD and PLM companies are in a full swing to embrace IoT technologies. Why not? IoT is probably the most...

22 December, 2011

After my publication PLM, Autodesk and Cloud Wars Club few days ago, I received few comments from my readers trying...

Blogroll

To the top