A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

From CAD file versions comparison to cloud PDM

From CAD file versions comparison to cloud PDM
Oleg
Oleg
21 December, 2013 | 2 min for reading

compare-cad-versions

A trend towards moving design related work to the cloud is growing. Despite a chorus of security, speed and connectivity concerned people, we can see how companies are growing their cloud data management solution towards supporting more robust features online. Few months ago, I was posting about Github moving towards the support of 3D models – GitHub PDM: is it for real? The ability of GitHub to work with 3D models together with core SCM functionality created an interesting tool for a specific market niche. Data management for individual designers, 3D printing offices and small teams.

Yesterday, my attention was caught by TechCrunch article – GitHub Adds 3D Modeling Features That Make It A Printer-Agnostic Choice For Object Sharing. Article speaks about GitHub adding a very specific 3D feature – ability to compare and finding difference in models. The following passage explains how it works.

…basically it takes each version and then overlays over the next using some nice transitions. Not unlike code diffs – the processes of comparing two iterations of a piece of software – this gives you far more control over the design process and lets you see where someone screwed up (or did something amazing).

Picture below shows how it looks like in the user interface:

github-rev-slider

Interesting enough, this feature reminded me another solution – GrabCAD CPD. GrabCAD recently introduced Workbench as part of their collaborative product development (CPD) suite. You can read my blog from last month – GrabCAD CPD wants to disrupt CAD file management. One of the GrabCAD Workbench features – visualization and comparison of versions.

grabcad-version-compare

Both GrabCAD and GitHub features made me think about new trend in cloud PDM development going bottom up and starting from very simple storage, file manipulation and sharing. Now it comes to revision comparison. Opposite to PDM dinosaurs trying to establish full top down file control and data management, these online tools are trying to find a right “feature” that will give them wide customer adoption.

What is my conclusion? Cloud provides an interesting opportunity to develop old solutions differently. GitHub and GrabCAD are not selling PDM first, but provide platforms for share data and compare revisions. Between these two, GrabCAD is probably looks more like a traditional PDM. GItHub popularity among software developers and SCM feature set can create an interesting perspective for different people in organization – software engineers, mechanical engineers, etc. to share the same platform. It means broader adoption – PDM industry was looking for these last 2 decades. Just my thoughts…

Best, Oleg

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
14 May, 2013

Delete is a special function. In the system dealing with the live data, the meaning of delete is interesting. My...

17 July, 2020

PDM is one of the topics I’m following for many years. CAD files created tons of challenges and to develop...

19 July, 2017

It is not a big secret that PLM vendors are stuck to provide a good solution for mid-size manufacturing companies....

3 November, 2016

Change management and PLM implementations are hard. You can check some of my earlier blogs to catch up on the...

21 September, 2010

Last week I had healthy debates with one of my blog readers about different options to deploy PLM for the...

28 October, 2014

  Few months ago, I posted about potential for Apple and IBM to open a door for mobile PLM future....

14 August, 2015

The roots of traditional PLM systems are in mechanical CAD systems. As a result, these PLM systems always had some...

3 December, 2012

The complexity of user interface in PLM applications is a well-known fact that acknowledged by almost all PLM vendors today....

8 July, 2016

For many years, customization was considered an unavoidable thing in enterprise software. At the earlier days, PLM system was a...

Blogroll

To the top