A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

Product Innovation Platform: I know it when I see it?

Product Innovation Platform: I know it when I see it?
Oleg
Oleg
2 December, 2016 | 4 min for reading

plm-product-innovation-platform-iknowheniseeit

Are you familiar with famous definition of pornography used in 1964 by United States Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart? Check Wikipedia article if you want to refresh your memory:

I shall not today attempt further to define the kinds of material I understand to be embraced within that shorthand description [“hard-core pornography”], and perhaps I could never succeed in intelligibly doing so. But I know it when I see it, and the motion picture involved in this case is not that.[4]

I think, PLM marketing is coming close to use this definition with regards to so called Product Innovation Platforms (PIP). You can catch up on my earlier articles about PIP – Sweet dreams about Product Innovation Platforms; Product Innovation Platform – architecture options; Product Innovation Platform: single vendor moustrap and agile services.

In my view, Product Innovation Platforms open a new wave of PLM competition. CIMdata commentary – A Product Innovation Platform and Its Impact on Successful PLM Deployments can give you some perspective on competitive positioning of vendors. Here is the passage:

Product innovation platforms are the foundation upon which functional capabilities, data, and processes are enabled—leading to the potential for much more innovation. Few PLM implementations, especially those based on monolithic solutions, achieve their goals and often end up as “instant” legacy PDM solutions that are not sustainable. A strong product innovation platform dramatically eases the burden of integrations with an enterprise’s broad range of PLM-enabling solutions. Aras Innovator provides an open and extensible product innovation platform that can be employed to provide an enterprise with a PLM solution that can grow into the future.

There are not so many PLM vendors in the world. So, monolithic PLM solutions list can be narrowed to 3DEXPERIENCE, Teamcenter and PTC Windchill and according to the passage these are are not sustainable systems. Opposite to old legacy platforms, Aras (open and extensible platform) can grow in the future. Enterprise integration and flexibility are defined as key elements that can help to make new Product Innovation Platform sustainable.

Many of today’s product lifecycle management (PLM) architectures have evolved from PDM solutions that were designed 30 or more years ago. While today’s architectures are greatly improved from what was available back then, the way they are applied in most PLM-enabling solutions still does not support easy integration with other enterprise platforms or solutions nor do they have the flexible capabilities needed for assimilating data, organization structures, and working processes to support the product lifecycle. The outcome is that companies must customize core data structures and solution processes to meet their particular business needs. As business needs change, future adaptations of the solutions become even more difficult, and upgrades, sometimes impossible.

CIMdata article brings a marketing picture of Aras platform with large number of applications addressing a diverse set of functional domains – System engineering, Product Engineering, Quality, Requirement Management, etc.

aras-pip-approach

I think that Aras made a great progress for the last 5 years since I published my article stating that Aras is moving towards displacement of major PLM platform vendors – ENOVIA, Teamcenter and Windchill. Take a look here.

At the same time, I found colorful marketing picture awfully similar to marketing materials coming from other PLM vendors. Take a look on the following picture capturing Windchill platform and its applications.

windchill-product-dev-system

What is my conclusion? Product Innovation Platform is an interesting concept. It addresses very important aspects of PLM deployment and architecture – openness, integration and sustainable deployment. Unfortunately, it is very hard to create a clear definition of Product Innovation Platform. We might see next wave of colorful marketing pictures with variety of boxes demonstrating new Product Innovation Platform approach. And it will be hard for manufacturing companies to identify which one is actually true Product Innovation Platform. So, “I know it when I see” can be a way to define it. It is a time for PLM vendors to be more specific in their definitions. Just my thoughts…

Best, Oleg

Want to learn more about PLM? Check out my new PLM Book website.

Disclaimer: I’m co-founder and CEO of openBoM developing cloud based bill of materials and inventory management tool for manufacturing companies, hardware startups and supply chain. My opinion can be unintentionally biased.

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
8 January, 2011

Bertrand Sicot appointed CEO of SolidWorks. In my view, it becomes a corporate news of this week. I think, almost...

30 May, 2013

Enterprise software sucks. How many times we’ve heard that for the last 5 years? Probably too many… I remember one...

30 June, 2010

I’d like to continue discussion of Openness and PLM (see my yesterday post – Closed Thoughts about PLM Openness) with...

4 June, 2019

I missed 2019 CIMdata Industry and Market forum earlier this year in Ann Arbor, MI. Stan Przybylinski of CIMdata was...

1 January, 2016

Happy New Year to all my readers. 2015 Year was amazing and I want to thank everyone for being with...

17 August, 2012

Think about the most overused term in PDM/PLM software for the last decade (or even more). Collaboration. It was developed...

28 July, 2024

In my recent article about the growing importance of Manufacturing BOM (MBOM) management, I explored various integration methods between CAD,...

9 July, 2020

SaaS PLM is trending and we’re going to see more SaaS PLMs marketing and sales coming from vendors very soon....

24 February, 2010

I found a very interesting Forbes Magazine’s story – The Future of Enterprise Software. The author is writing about coming...

Blogroll

To the top