A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

Achilles Heel of MBSE and PLM modeling

Achilles Heel of MBSE and PLM modeling
Oleg
Oleg
14 August, 2018 | 2 min for reading

Aras’ presentation by Pawel Chadzynski MBSE and the Business of Engineering brings some interesting perspective of what Aras is thinking about model driven system engineering. I can see a growing interest in model-driven approach, but not much agreement how things supposed to work. In a nutshell, everyone agrees that model is a good thing and if we can apply ‘model’ to serve our needs, then organizations can get lot of benefits from variety of aspects – data traceability, early data exploration, change management and more.

Aras’ slide deck does an excellent job presenting complexity of production development. The visualization of circles and with colored nodes-network is really neat. I like it.

Things are getting a bit more complex when you go into some implementation slides mapping  MBSE models with PLM structures. I like the slide.

However, it made me think about few potential complexity challenges (1) change complexity; (2) organization complexity.

1- Change complexity

The static model looks nice and allows you to have full traceability of data. It gives you a tremendous value. However, I was trying to image the change in this structure and things were shaking because of multiple changes that can happen simultaneously in a model of connections, changes, revisions, versions and structures. This is a moment when change model can conflict with collaboration model. The transactions can be dead-locked or apply to old data. I’d was looking for change management diagram, but presentation doesn’t have one.

2- Organization complexity 

To apply organizational structure into this model can be even more interesting experiment. PLM and MBSE models are not mentioning organizational boundaries. Once applied, can trigger a question of database boundaries. If an entire structure is managed as a single tenant, it will most probably survive. But then everybody in an entire organization of OEMs, Tier 1…n, contractors and suppliers will be using the same PLM database. The reality might be different and it will introduce another level of complexity in the implementation (organizational silos).

What is my conclusion? I like the model of connecting PLM structures with extended information sets of system engineering domain. However, I’m curious how both change management and organizational complexity can be managed. Although, I can see a value even in a read only structure connecting domains of information. But, the notion of Enterprise ECM assumes some dynamic behavior and the reality of distributed work can demand companies to work in multiple databases or event more complex architecture to support it. How to solve these problems is a topic for another blog. Just my thoughts…

Best, Oleg

Want to learn more about PLM? Check out my new PLM Book website.

Disclaimer: I’m co-founder and CEO of OpenBOM developing cloud based bill of materials and inventory management tool for manufacturing companies, hardware startups and supply chain. My opinion can be unintentionally biased.

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
18 July, 2015

One of the topics I’m following closely these days is cloud CAD development trend. To make cloud CAD work from...

29 October, 2021

The question of standards is the one that always touches the nerve of PLM people. Stan Przybylinski did again by...

4 July, 2025

In my recent blog about the CIMdata Industry and Market Forum in Ann Arbor, I highlighted a recurring theme that...

9 July, 2012

I want to talk about the cloud today. However, I don’t want to speak about PLM cloud. I want to...

2 November, 2018

I’m getting ready to my presentation at PLMx Chicago event next week. Check my earlier blog – PLMx discussion from...

28 July, 2009

My short conclusion after very productive discussion about how to move PLM to mainstream. First of all, I enjoyed it...

3 March, 2010

You can tag almost everything these days – products on Amazon, Photos on Flikr, Facebook friends… However, would you think...

6 September, 2010

I decided to make an unusual post today. Because of holiday (Labor Day in USA), I spent most of the...

12 October, 2019

Earlier today, my attention was caught by PLM Stack article – Should you care about the programming language used in...

Blogroll

To the top