A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

Product and Process Models in PLM – What Should Come First?

Product and Process Models in PLM – What Should Come First?
olegshilovitsky
olegshilovitsky
3 December, 2009 | 2 min for reading

Common definition of the process: “a set of activities leading to the desired outcome.” Despite such a simple and straightforward definition, the implementation of processes in PLM is often delayed and very frequently leads to significant complexity in implementation. I’d like to analyze and discover why this happens and what other factors can influence process implementation in an organization.

Process Model

Depending on the tools, technologies, and environment a customer has, processes in the organization can be modeled and implemented differently. Normally, there is more than one enterprise system in the organization capable of handling process modeling. Starting with middleware and specialized BPM software, followed by enterprise systems such as ERP and PLM, and ending with various Enterprise 2.0 collaboration tools, process models these days can be developed using multiple tools. Over the last few years, BPMN has become somewhat similar to a standard process definition tool. What is the main problem? Data. Various products and corporate data need to be injected into process implementation to make it work.

Product (Data) Model

Originally starting with CAD models, the product model has developed into an extended set of information describing various aspects and dimensions of a product—model, bill of material, requirements, items, information about customer requests, etc. As we learned from the process model definition, this specific product model information is needed to enable process definition. Processes actually need to access data to trigger tasks and events for handling processes.

So, what should come first? Product or Process?

My conclusion is that the lack of a rational product model can lead to a very high level of complexity in process definition and implementation. The product model is the foundation of the product lifecycle. Without a well-defined product model that can cover the enterprise product definition scope and related disciplines, the development of a process-oriented PLM environment becomes a complex and unachievable task. Organizations implementing PLM as a process environment need to invest first in the implementation or adoption of a product model that will serve as the foundation for processes.

What is your opinion?

What has been your experience with similar tasks and efforts?

Best,
Oleg

Disclaimer: I’m the co-founder and CEO of OpenBOM, a digital-thread platform providing cloud-native collaborative services including PDM, PLM, and ERP capabilities. With extensive experience in federated CAD-PDM and PLM architecture, I’m advocates for agile, open product models and cloud technologies in manufacturing. My opinion can be unintentionally biased

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
13 September, 2011

I have a feeling “cloud” topic got some dominance for the last days and week. However, the following article about...

15 July, 2016

PLM is transforming from pure engineering discipline into platform capable to manage a diverse set of data and processes. I...

2 June, 2010

I had chance to read an article in SD time – Organization works to blend application, product life-cycle management. Author...

9 November, 2016

“Two engineers. Three opinions”. You probably heard this joke before. This is a reality of engineering world. In my view...

15 December, 2017

For many years, to have CAD system installed on a very powerful workstation was the only option to design something...

4 March, 2009

According to the latest supply research done by IBM,, one of the challenges of the supply chain having to manage...

28 January, 2014

Engineering and Manufacturing software requires some learning. I hope even biggest promoters of to make “single button PLM application” would...

3 December, 2012

The complexity of user interface in PLM applications is a well-known fact that acknowledged by almost all PLM vendors today....

4 February, 2010

This short prompt today was driven by presentation on SolidWorks World 2010. What is the evolution path of PLM? For...

Blogroll

To the top