A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

PLM Migration and Product Data Rock-n-Roll

PLM Migration and Product Data Rock-n-Roll
Oleg
Oleg
29 December, 2010 | 3 min for reading

I read The PLM State: PLM Migration, No Data Left Behind on Zero-Wait State blog. Read it and make your opinion. Stephen Porter is discussing a very important topic of data migration. I found it interesting. This is my favorite passage:

…leaving data behind is not necessarily a bad thing since it can corrupt and handicap your new system. Spending time up front to fully assess your information is time well spent. Segmenting data and moving it over in portions is a viable strategy for facilitating cleanup and assessment. Using the target PLM system as a filter and cleaning mechanism can be an effective way to manage migration.

The conclusion made by Stephen made me think about product data value and data migration problems.

Data Value

Most of the companies I have seen for the last year are dying in the ocean of product data. Company creates data every day. It comes out of the company design and engineering, manufacturing, support, sales, marketing and service. In my view,  data is one of the biggest company assets. Companies are accumulating data for a very long period of time. In some industries, legacy data retention is part of the regulation rules and requirements.

Product Data Rock-n-Roll

According to the latest survey of Cyon Research, the majority of customers are dissatisfied with PDM software. Companies are looking how to improve the way to manage product data and thinking about how to optimize and consolidate PDM packages. Here is the quote from Cyon Research 2010 Survey of Engineering Software User:

Among the major classes of software, customers are most dissatisfied with their PDM systems. More than 25% of SMBs and 30% of large firms were either in the process of switching PDM systems or had just switched within the past two years, about twice the rate of change for CAD or CAE systems. 45% of large firms are going through or have just gone through a consolidation of PDM software.

The consolidation of PDM software will obviously raise the question of data migration and potential losses of companies due to their inability to move data from a previous system. Another practice is to continue using an old system in parallel with a new system to access data. The last option often becomes a much more cost effective for a company compared to the investment needed to migrate data between systems. The result is a lot of legacy data sources and systems. In the past, I wrote about different aspects of legacy data handling. The importance of legacy data for a company is absolute and very undervalued in modern PDM/PLM systems.

What is my conclusion? The complexity of product data management systems created a situation when migration of data between systems can cause a significant loss of value. Competition between software vendors in this domain adds additional difficulties. In my view, to clean the historical data record, as a result of multiple system migrations, is a very bad idea. To have an ability to migrate product data from one system to another can be a significant product differentiation factor. Just my thoughts…

Best, Oleg

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
12 December, 2013

Identification. When it comes to data management it is a very important thing. In product data management and PLM it...

25 May, 2010

What do you think about PLM standards? My take is that standards like toothbrushes – everybody wants it, but nobody...

25 February, 2011

CAD and PLM world is extremely competitive. The decision process in the manufacturing industry is not fast. Companies are spending...

7 August, 2022

I was catching up on some of the social media reading over the weekend. My attention was caught by Deloitte’s...

29 February, 2016

Part Number is a fundamental element of any identification mechanism in product development and manufacturing. The debates about intelligent and...

22 April, 2015

I’m following Aras PLM annual event online this week – ACE2015. There is a moderate volume of tweets coming from...

25 February, 2014

Metadata is “data about data”. If you stay long with PDM industry, you probably remember how earlier EDM/PDM software defined...

20 July, 2009

I think we are moving fast toward combination of virtual and physical worlds. How we can get closer and combine...

17 June, 2016

I’m digesting information from Autodesk Forge DevCon event I attended earlier this week in San Francisco. One of the technical...

Blogroll

To the top