Why Apple isn’t cool for engineers? Or you are here to work…

by Oleg on July 8, 2011 · View Comments

Apple isn’t cool.. Got your attention? Okay… Today is two years, since I switched my everyday life to MacBook. It is enough time to make some conclusion. I was almost ready to write my next blog post as some kind of “My last two years with MacBook Pro“, but I stumbled on the following article – Keep it in your pants – Pet Peeve#1 in CAD Insider, written by Roopinder Tara. Spend few minutes to read that blog. The following passage is my lovely one:

I don’t have any Apple computers. Nor am I yearning for one. My daughter is. She is way cooler than me. But when I look around, I don’t see any engineer using them. Not for production work. Just writing this will ensure that I will be pelted by Mac enthusiasts, but like mysterious forces others insist upon, I still deny their existence without visual proof.

So, despite the fact I can be classified as “a blogger going on rants“, I decided to put few stories related to what, in my view, is going around PC/Windows, Apple and engineers working in manufacturing companies.

You are here to work, not to play.

Does anybody remember this phrase? Actually, I do… very well. It was a very common answer on the complains about software that (to say politely) “less usable” than expected. Business software was built for business and not for a game. So, everybody supposed to RTFM and work with the software purchased by a company. I think it was very acceptable 10 years ago. However, voices of people that started to ask about usable software becomes more and more louder. Companies like SolidWorks proved that user experience does matter. Finally, I can see more and more engineers looking how to use cool software.

This is such a useless device…

This statement belongs to the engineering manager of one of the very respectful manufacturing company in US. And the device is “iPad 1″. The conversation actually happened a year ago, and it was about few months after iPad was released to the market. When we are still waiting for evidence of a massive migration of manufacturing companies to iPad, I think this event is not as far somebody can image. I found the following example interesting (even if it comes from non-manufacturing domain). The article from NYT says the story about the legal firm migrating a few hundreds attorneys to iPad.

This week, Proskauer Rose, one of the nation’s largest law firms, began making iPad 2s available to all its lawyers. So far, 500 of the firm’s 700 lawyers have requested an iPad and a desktop computer over a laptop.

Btw, Few weeks ago, I got an email from the same engineering manager saying – “I’m starting to believe that you may be on to something with iPads…“. Since the last time, we talked the same manufacturing company he is working for, switched completely from Blackberries to iPhones.

Visual Proof

Now let me talk about “visual proof“. When I switched my life to MacBook pro, two years ago, very few of my closest friends and colleagues were running on Apple. However, going back in 2007 and 2008, I noticed a growing number of Apple computers around me on conferences and in public places. Back that time, my corporate laptop was IBM/Thinkpad. Two years later, I can see many people around me switched their lives to Apple computers. Enterprises and manufacturing companies are moving much slower, but it is just a matter of time.

What is my conclusion? Let me think about a computer as a device with its own lifecycle. It was a time computer was big, bulky and took a whole room in your company. These big computers proved their existence by solving particular unsolved problems. Microsoft made computers smaller and affordable. Thinking about post-PC era, I can see people considering computers a device that helps them to get an everyday job done. And it should take fewer hassle, problems, calling specialists or IT. So, criteria changes and it will definitely change the landscape of computer devices we are using. Just my thoughts…

Best, Oleg

  • Share/Bookmark
  • Kiddo2050

    I think your timing on this is a bit late. With the release of windows 8 this year the Apple era will begin to end. People switched to macs because they were more stable than XP and prettier. With windows 7 the first part was solved and right about now we are starting to see some beautiful pc laptops. Add to this a windows 8 which has a much more beautiful interface than a mac and Apple is going to look very dated very fast.

    When you step back it's really very simple, Apple cannot hope to stay ahead of a whole tribe of firms from Samsung to Sony to Acer. It's like 10 designers against 1. Think about it. In the 90s people sais we want cheap laptops and these guys fought to deliver that. Now people are saying laptops are cheap enough we want them to be beautiful, and they are going to get it. Apple has only one design industrial silver. It cannot hope to get a large market share when people have decent alternatives. We don't dress the same or drive the same cars or live in the same houses, why should we all have the same computers and phones?

  • beyondplm

    Thanks for your insight, Kiddo205! 
    I agree with you. Windows 8 and new ultrabooks from other hardware manufacturers are finally coming, and it is improved significantly (compared to XP version and previous model of laptops 3-5 years ago). The only thing I can put as an answer - Imitation is the grandest form of flattery! It is always good to have competitive forces. 
    Btw, interesting how you define as "Apple Era". 1976? 1998? 2007?http://upload.wikimedia.org/wi..., Oleg

  • Interesting view Oleg. We are going to see a proliferation of new devices as more apps move to the cloud (yes, I said cloud). But it won't be without hiccups. My switch to Apple has not been entirely easy because a lot of things just don't work on it. I ended up running a Windows Virtual Machine (using Parallel) in order to run some of my existing software. I was hoping the issue would go away with Internet/browser based applications. But I have now had bad experiences with Webex and Livemeeting (OK, no surprise that wants to run in IE). But software is going to need to be increasingly agnostic to devices and browsers and just work as more people are using alternative devices. I love my Mac, but it just doesn't work with everything yet. I am not talking about engineering software, just personal productivity. As for the iPad and PLM - I am a big fan as you can see in my report "Taking PLM Mobile" http://www.tech-clarity.com/ov...

    PS - I will have to go read Roopinder's article, what a great title! (assuming he is talking iPhone...)

  • beyondplm

    Jim, Thanks for comments and link to your blog! Yes, Roopinder is talkin' about iPhone. Thanks for sharing your Mac experience. I shifted to GoToMeeting- it is kinda stable on Mac (at least better than LiveMeeting and WebEx). I switched to Office for Mac and run Parallels only when I need CAD like SolidWorks and PC is not available. Best, oelg

blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: