A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

Amazon Outage and Fake PLM Cloudification

Amazon Outage and Fake PLM Cloudification
Oleg
Oleg
6 March, 2017 | 3 min for reading

networked-cloud-plm

Last week Amazon outage was a splashing event for everything related to cloud  computing. Amazon S3 in east cost went down and knocked out many cloud services around the world. In CAD / PLM ecosystem it was almost a silent event. Autodesk cloud infrastructure partially went down. Also GrabCAD informed customers about problem. All other PLM vendors kept radio silence.

I’ve been following multiple articles after the event providing variety of opinion about how to trust (or not) cloud infrastructure. I also been asked by some of my readers online and offline if cloud providers can be trusted and how reliable cloud platforms for the future of mission critical systems such as PLM.

My favorite article was Infoworld’s AWS outage proves one cloud isn’t enough. Thanks Stan Przybylinski for sharing it online. The main point of the article is dead simple. The idea of cloud computing is not about how to stuck your PLM server in the cloud and claim reduced IT cost and effort, but to provide a reliable fault tolerant cloud infrastructure. I like the following passage:

All of this means you need to develop a system that tolerates latency. Your fake cloudification, where you stuck SQL Server in the cloud and plonked a load balancer in front, isn’t likely to cut it without real thought and re-engineering.

And the following passage gives you a recipe in a nutshell – horizontal scale and cheap redundancy will rock the future.

In the past, companies set up multiple data centers, WAN replication, redundant DNS, clustered services … all these have been doable, albeit less affordable in the past. But today’s database technology, micro-services architecture, and vastly improved software make redundancy much cheaper and easier. But don’t get hung up on using only one provider’s offerings.

It made me think about existing PLM platforms architectures and their ability to follow new new type of architectures. You probably remember my article Will PLM microservices eat PLM dinosaurs?  Existing PLM platforms are going back 15-20 years in the lifecycle of development and multiple acquisitions. These platforms are mostly monolithic application and servers relying on database architecture to store and manage data. One of the biggest problem of existing architectures is move from one product to another or to update existing products. The monolithic application nature makes that problem very painful. New cloud architectures can provide an alternative by bringing a set of microservices and replace existing product with new type of cloud agile platforms.

What is my conclusion? New PLM architectures should kill single point of failure. For many existing PLM platforms SQL driven backed is the one to kill. But it is not simple when PLM vendors are hiding Oracle or SQL server driven tenant oriented applications behind IaaS infrastructure. Highly available, redundant cloud architectures is the future of new sustainable PLM platforms. The one that can sustain next AWS outage. This is a note to PLM architects of the future. Just my thoughts…

Best, Oleg

Want to learn more about PLM? Check out my new PLM Book website.

Disclaimer: I’m co-founder and CEO of openBoM developing cloud based bill of materials and inventory management tool for manufacturing companies, hardware startups and supply chain. My opinion can be unintentionally biased.

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
24 December, 2013

Customization is one of the most favorite topics in PLM. Back 20-30 years ago, product data management (PDM) was born...

14 April, 2015

PLM sales is not an easy job. PLM is usually “sold” to companies… or actually sold to people running product...

12 August, 2009

Product Lifecycle Management pretend to manage everything in the organization that related to product, information about product, development IP etc...

30 January, 2025

I’m preparing for 3DEXPERIENCE World 2025, which will take place in Houston, TX, in a few weeks. For many years,...

12 August, 2013

An unusual topic for today. I read The Guardian article Google’s Sergey Brin bankrolled world’s first synthetic beef hamburger. Navigate...

29 July, 2011

Let me talk again about Part Numbers. The last time I wrote about Part Numbers, it created a healthy discussion....

5 August, 2022

There are a lot of factors to consider when it comes to choosing the best PLM systems and solutions for...

28 February, 2018

PDM (or PLM) was born as idea of centralization of data and processes under single roof (actually database).  Back 30-40...

2 November, 2015

Integration is an important element of manufacturing. Time ago, the meaning of integration was to build a manufacturing factory which...

Blogroll

To the top