A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

PLM single tenant model – dead end?

PLM single tenant model – dead end?
Oleg
Oleg
12 September, 2018 | 3 min for reading

I tried to visualize single tenant PLM model and global manufacturing. Here is the result and it looks ugly…

The days when manufacturing companies was associated with a single build workshop building are gone. Manufacturing companies today are global enterprises with the manufacturing facilities located in multiple places, contractors, suppliers and customers. The complexity of the relationships between these companies is high and it is skyrocketing multiplied by complexity of product and customers.

Cloud has come of age and manufacturing companies are exploring how to leverage cloud models and new applications in the most efficient way.  Very often, it brings a question about single-vs-mult-tenant architectures. You can check my earlier blog – how to ask right questions about multi-tenant architectures.

Today, I took a different approach. I’ve made an attempt to visualize an architecture of existing PLM systems and and possible relationships between companies, data and systems.

Let’s think about fictitious manufacturing company developing industrial equipment  and using contractors, suppliers and customers world wide. It is not hard to imagine such company as well as the number of contractors and suppliers. I downgraded the number to minimum to create the following chart.

Think about enterprise systems used by each of these companies. The reality of manufacturing is that every single company in this diagram will run some database driven system to manage design data, bill of materials, purchase order, procurement and customer data. With the growing demand for connectivity, a typical solution will be to use Excel and email to transfer data between companies.

Excel is bad, but what is the alternative? Companies understood how bad is the situation. Even so, the alternative proposed by traditional PLM architecture is also questionable. Imagine every manufacturing companies deploying PLM system in such a way they can centralize data and communication. Majority of existing PLM software architecture is represented by a single tenant database models. With the growing amount of relationships between companies and the need to share information, the picture is getting messy very fast.

Check this image below on which I attempted to visualize a potential relationships between 4 manufacturing companies, their contractors, suppliers and service organization. Suppliers and contractors are manufacturing companies as well, so the number of single-database PLM units will be growing and very soon can become not manageable.

What is my conclusion? Complexity of products multiplied by complexity of business relationships and communication. This is a reality of manufacturing companies these days. Single tenant application model was invented back in days the focus of the companies was how to control information inside of a company. Business today is much more connected. Contract manufacturing, suppliers, outsourcing – these are just few examples. The reality of manufacturing is that it doesn’t fit anymore into single tenant model. New data management concepts should be developed to support manufacturing companies in 21st century. Just my thoughts…

Best, Oleg

Disclaimer: I’m co-founder and CEO of OpenBOM developing cloud based bill of materials and inventory management tool for manufacturing companies, hardware startups and supply chain. My opinion can be unintentionally biased

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
23 March, 2019

I’m coming to Aras PLM event (ACE2019). It has been a long time since I visited ACE event in person. Eight years...

15 January, 2009

For many years, data management was considered as something that burdens the activity of designers and engineers focused on CAD...

21 February, 2017

Last week I blogged about PLM selection politics. People are hard and political games in an organization are unavoidable.Existing PLM...

10 September, 2010

I’m going to join this first COFES Russia event on 21th September. Earlier this week David Levin of LEDAS announced his vision...

11 February, 2017

Interesting things are happening with Solidworks PDM these days. I’ve been following Solidworks World 2017 event earlier this week in...

19 July, 2010

My new website and blog is BeyondPLM. The original post is here. If you listened to the news stream from Microsoft...

29 November, 2016

PLM industry is in a full swing to promote new concepts – digital thread and digital twin. While digital term by itself...

27 October, 2020

Moment PLM articles about the role, responsibilities, and desired skills of PLM architects caught my attention earlier this week. Check...

9 December, 2020

The discussions around cloud SaaS PLM are heating up. Like a decade ago, when the engineering software industry just started...

Blogroll

To the top