A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

CAD is boring… because CAD is alone!

CAD is boring…  because CAD is alone!
olegshilovitsky
olegshilovitsky
29 January, 2009 | 2 min for reading

I was reading an interview with Chris Williams about his new product, Vuuch, on NOVEDGE. Chris said that “the CAD world is boring…”. But I’m wondering why? I thought that the data management world (PDM, ERP) is more boring since it’s all about grids of data.  But CAD? This is about really great pictures of nice cars, executive jets, incredible yachts, etc… then I started to realize what happened. I think CAD developed as a very deep silo, from the user standpoint as well as from the organizational standpoint. CAD does not allow people to expose everything that CAD creates to the outside i.e. the engineering world. As you know, almost everything from the design world ends up in PDF format. Because CAD doesn’t exist in the outside world, a lot of intelligence, information, design content just dead after result of CAD goes to outside world.

I think that association with MRP/MRP II systems is very appropriated in this context. In the beginning of MRP, the scope of MRP was to manage manufacturing materials. Beyond MRPII, was the idea of managing a wider scope of data – materials, finance and resources. The shift from MRP to MRPII allowed the connection of these three data silos together. Future transformation from MRPII to ERP added additional scopes of data and processes beyond manufacturing to be integrated all together.

So, what I see as the fundamental goal is to allow CAD content to be available in various forms outside of the design space. CAD silos need to be connected to other aspects of engineering and non-engineering activities. This will build more business value around CAD and ultimately create more value for organizations and users. I think this space is open for disruptive innovative technologies that will make changes in this space similar to introduction of parametric modeling in CAD, creating of 3D CAD on top of Windows, and some others. Today’s design content requires modernization, using more efficient and cheap technologies that will link the outside world to CAD.

Clayton M. Christensen, author of “The Innovator’s Dilemma” shows that sustained innovation, even funded by billion dollar research budgets, only enables leading companies to survive as long as no disruptive technology suddenly appears to upset the corporate apple-cart. I believe that new PLM, Digital Prototyping, BIM or any other technologies that will come to this space need to be more social, more open and more reliable compared to what we have today. And… CAD 2.0 or PLM 3.0, or whatever TLA (three letter acronym) product will be developed in today’s world, in my opinion, will definitely not be boring…

Check out Ivan Sutherland’s movie on Sketchpad. How do you feel when you look at your 15 year old computer today? Funny, isn’t it? I’m sure that CAD/PLM of today will appear just as funny in the future as the CAD of 25 years ago seems today.

[youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mOZqRJzE8xg]

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
23 June, 2010

I had chance to have a talk with David Siegel, entrepreneur, speaker and the author of a new book “Pull“....

11 November, 2018

PLM space is active these days. The activities are also for large companies and small ones. Just few months ago,...

20 February, 2017

Develop3D article – Kenesto Drive 2.0 updates cloud product document management, collaboration and version control brings a news about Kenesto Drive...

25 September, 2018

The news just came – Aras is acquiring Comet Solutions. Check Aras press release for more details. Here is a passage...

10 September, 2010

Yesterday discussion about PLM usability made me think more about how to come with ideas to improve usability of PLM...

19 November, 2023

I’m bringing more notes and insight about Autodesk University 2023 I attended last week. If you missed my earlier articles,...

10 March, 2012

Few weeks ago, during SolidWorks World 2012, Bernard Charles, President and CEO of Dassault System announced 3D Experience. I posted...

7 September, 2019

One of the most popular discussions in the PLM domain is about what is PLM. The debates are going on...

27 October, 2017

Single version of truth is a mantra sold by most of enterprise software vendors. PLM is included. I think, PLM...

Blogroll

To the top