A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

3 main factors of mainstream PLM adoption

3 main factors of mainstream PLM adoption
olegshilovitsky
olegshilovitsky
27 July, 2009 | 3 min for reading

plm-mainstreamI had chance to discuss PLM adoption rate already several time. I think, adoption rate, is one of the factors why Product Lifecycle Management is not coming to mainstream and remains something exclusive. If I look back in the computer and CAD industry history, the revolutions happened when sophisticated technologies were moved from exclusive and more expensive environment to mainstream. Microsoft did it for PC, John Walker and his partners moved from exclusive CAD workstations to mainstream PC in 1982, SolidWorks took all experience Pro-E developed until 1995 and revolutionized it on Windows platform.

So, what I had in my mind over this weekend is to think more about how to find roots for expensive and complicated PLM implementations. What those factors that make them so complicated and maybe to put few initial thoughts about how to move them to mainstream. I thought about every PLM implementation I had chance to touch and came to a conclusion that the following three major factors or steps are always causing complexity and cost: 1/Customization; 2/Legacy data; 3/Integration with ERP and other systems.

#1 – Customization.
This is a very significant piece of every PLM implementation. I hardly believe in “typical manufacturing environment”. Yes, definitely, there is some general similarity based on industry or organization type, but fundamentally people are running manufacturing differently, have their own environment, semantics of data, customized name schemas etc. So, cost to customize PLM system to get it to the right level is quite significant. To have right customization tools and integrated programming environment is key to success here. Everything is possible in software – we know that. However, what will be cost of these “possibilities”?

#2 – Legacy Data
In order to run your manufacturing environment, you need to have “your data” in the system. Without this, you are not actually running your manufacturing with PLM. To get legacy data in the system is a very painful task, in my view. I have almost never seen this happened easy. This is almost every time set of complicated steps of exporting and importing data. Since, there is no standard data, we back partially to factor #1 (customization) again.

#2 – Integration with ERP
This is last, but not least. The first chain in product development PLM needs to support is integration with ERP. If you don’t have integration with ERP implemented, you have closed environment that almost cannot optimize your manufacturing. Most of the product cost driving factors these days are on the intersection of product requirements, design and manufacturing and supply chain capabilities. To make integration with ERP is #1 task for PLM.

So, what is my short conclusion? These three factors can move every PLM implementation to nightmare. In today’s modern PLM systems, I had chance to follow few possible solutions to resolve these issues. Most PLM providers these days are focusing on industries, verticals and best practices. Not bad step in my view. As much closer you will come to final environment, less time you will spend to customize final environment. From integration and customization standpoint, moving to Microsoft development environment, Visual Basic and script based customization can be very efficient to decrease cost of implementation.
Even if I don’t think, these solutions are completely successful, but they definitely can bring some pain relief. However, I do believe, the right solutions are probably still in the future.

I’m looking forward to your comment and thoughts. I’d be glad to learn about your experience.
Best, Oleg.

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
28 May, 2010

I had chance to read a WordCAD Access post by Ralf Grabowski – So, how much will CAD on cloud cost?...

27 May, 2009

Web 2.0 and following 2.0 technologies came to us a few years ago (around 2003 and 2004) and changed the...

23 September, 2020

It’s so difficult to see what is going on when you’re in the middle of something? It’s only with hindsight...

24 October, 2014

The number of SaaS businesses is growing these days. You probably had a chance to read my CAD, PLM and...

30 January, 2020

ROI of PLM is not measurable. To sell PLM you need to create a myth. This statement of Jos Voksuil...

16 June, 2015

Culture can eat strategy for breakfast and technology for lunch. When it comes to PLM, the implementation and organizational alignment...

22 August, 2021

Data is taking a central stage in everything that businesses do these days. You can hear about digital strategies and...

31 August, 2011

Collaboration is an important thing. I think you agree with me. However, speaking about collaboration how many of you are...

30 January, 2012

Cloud is hyping in 2012. Coming Facebook IPO can only supercharge the future of cloud computing. Last year Autodesk announcement...

Blogroll

To the top