A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

PLM: Hug Your Data or Federate?

PLM: Hug Your Data or Federate?
olegshilovitsky
olegshilovitsky
13 January, 2010 | 2 min for reading

Last year I had chance to blog about why PLM Is Too Complex To Mashup? Thinking about Enterprise PLM implementations, I’m always coming to the following conclusion about the way PLM is managing data – PLM system strategically trying to define, own and manage the complete product data cycle and every aspect related to this data inside and outside of the enterprise. Now, in my view, by doing so, PLM put their effort as a very confronted to the other enterprise systems. This behavior is not typical for PLM- other “enterprise animals” are also trying to keep data closely to their core databases and vaults.

Data Hugging

So, I can call this behavior “data hugging”. Is it good and beneficial? From the certain perspective, you can think about this as a good option to centralize data management and control the situation in your organization related to Product Data or any other topic managed in the context of Product Data. However, the reality is different. Such data hugging can create a situation where get full information is quite complicated.

Federation

What are the alternatives? Data Federation is another alternative. Connect data in your system to the data in another system using so called Proxy objects. The idea of the federation has a potential, since it doesn’t require movement of data around between applications on logical and sometime even on the physical level. However, data federation can be quite complicated for implementation and requires explicit connections between systems.

Other options

If you understand the problem of “data hugging” and don’t think a federation can work out with your environment. DW (Data Warehousing) and MDM (Master Data Management) are two related directions and technologies, that can give you a different perspective in federating data across your company.

What is my conclusion today? Companies are struggling between two possible options – to give extreme power to business and enterprise application to hug data inside or to allow data federation inside organization. The first option is promising for the first look. The hidden portion of the “single system” message is the need to move data from everyplace in your organization to this system. This is not a simple decision in my view. Different flavors of the federation can be perceived as a more complex option upfront, however, can provide a more balanced data management solution for the long term. New disruptive solutions coming from outside of enterprise (mashups are one of them) can provide an interesting alternative for tomorrow’s enterprise data management. What the route PLM systems and implementation should take? What is your opinion?

Best, Oleg

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
3 July, 2019

Unless you’ve been under the rock for the last five years, you’ve heard about DevOps. Still confused about DevOps? Start...

20 October, 2010

The following message on twitter from Jonathan Scott of Razorleaf made me think about the future of vertical integration in...

26 June, 2009

Well, Product Lifecycle Management sounds like a very profound concept. I can see organizational benefits, values, etc… etc… But I’m...

18 June, 2015

Enterprise integration is a messy space. It is always complex – applications, databases, new and legacy systems, complexity of requirements....

24 August, 2012

I’m preparing myself for Social PLM 2012 virtual conference in 2 weeks. It is a time to re-think all what...

14 December, 2017

2017 was a year of chatbots. I posted about chatbots a year ago in my article  Will chatbots simplify user experience?...

13 November, 2022

People don’t want something really new. They want to have something they are familiar with but work differently. In today’s...

27 January, 2021

Unless you lived under the rock for the last several years, you’ve heard about SaaSification. This funny term was changing...

7 October, 2013

Do you remember live without Google? It was only 15 years ago. You should agree, information was less available back...

Blogroll

To the top