A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

Will cloud CAD inherit data interoperability problem?

Will cloud CAD inherit data interoperability problem?
Oleg
Oleg
3 March, 2015 | 2 min for reading

cloud-cad-pdm-interop

Cloud and CAD are probably getting to the point where it starts become a real thing. Autodesk Fusion360, Onshape, SolidWork Industrial design. It is likely to absorb some PDM functionality to make collaboration, branching, revisions and other data management tasks easier. Cloud CAD means no files, so engineers have nothing to mess with… Life is getting more Googley if you read John McEleney Onshape blog.

However, here is the thing… What if (for some crazy reason, which is easy to imagine when you deal with engineers :)), customer will decide to do a work with two cloud CAD systems? It is not unusual to see multiple desktop CAD systems in engineering organizations, so why cloud CAD will be any different.

In my yesterday blog –  Cloud CAD infrastructure is getting more PDM-ish, I draw the picture of cloud CAD/PDM bundle helping us to collaborate and manage revisions. Now how two cloud CAD systems will work together? I’ve been trying to bring my cloud imagination and thought about Google Docs and Office 365 services co-existence. Actually, it is not very nice story- I can easy get my files distributed between my Dropbox, Google Drive and OneDrive accounts. So, what if my parts will be stored on Google Drive and Assembly on Dropbox? Not sure I will like it…

Similar problem in PLM world created many debates and issues. Do you remember Dassault CATIA V6 story, which required ENOVIA backend to run it? It made few customers unhappy when they discovered that they need to run two PDM/PLM systems.  I can see some similarity with multiple CAD/PDM cloud bundles co-existence and interoperability.

What is my conclusion? How engineers will collaborate using multiple CAD cloud software? Cloud technology is great, but it looks like cannot magically resolve some old fundamental problems of multiple systems, collaboration and interoperability. I wish cloud CAD / PDM vendors will think about it upfront before customers will find themselves in the middle of messy CAD / import/export/migrate data scenarios. Just my thoughts…

Best, Oleg

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
13 September, 2010

In my view, “Free” is continuing to pull people. Recently, I’ve seen few articles in PLM Blogosphere that was talking...

8 May, 2018

People are hard. We know that. There are so many articles written about complexity of changes, people management and PLM...

8 February, 2017

Timing is one of the most interesting and important elements success or failure of any projects. Right technology in a...

2 August, 2010

I read news from the last week – Chrysler Group LLC contracts with Siemens PLM software for product design and development...

28 March, 2013

Are you reading whitepapers these days? Hmm… Not much you can say, probably. I’m reading blogs, twitter streams and use...

26 September, 2019

Earlier this week I attended TEC Talk. This is almost traditional gathering organized by TechSoft3D – a software outfit selling...

6 June, 2011

Recently, I’ve been in a very interesting conversation with one of my industry buddies. It was about a role PDM...

19 October, 2010

Few days ago, I run into Gartner Magic Quadrant about IT Project and Portfolio Management. You can get it by...

22 December, 2017

Every PLM implementation means lot of integration services. I hardly can remember at least one PLM implementation that was done...

Blogroll

To the top