A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

BOM and Product Data in Excel – What’s for Breakfast?

BOM and Product Data in Excel – What’s for Breakfast?
Oleg
Oleg
31 January, 2025 | 3 min for reading

Peter Druker said, “Culture eats strategy for breakfast and then stays hungry all day”. In many manufacturing companies, people store product data in Excel, folders, and zip files. It’s quick and easy, like fast food. But just like eating McDonald’s every day, it seems fine at first but causes big problems later for manufacturing processes, ordering of raw materials and broad range of production and supply chain issues.

The Fast Food Approach to Product Data

Engineers and manufacturers work hard and do what’s easiest. They put product data in spreadsheets and shared folders because it’s simple and familiar. The problem? No one is thinking about the big picture. Over time, this habit creates a mess of disconnected spreadsheets, lost files, and outdated information. Mechanical and electronic engineers send two Excels to procurement person and she needs to figure out why number of components is different (ah… mechanical parts and electronics are not identical.. )

This “fast food” approach may work for a while, but it leads to big problems. Procurement teams can’t find the latest part lists, supply chain teams chase missing data, and production teams get incorrect instructions, causing costly mistakes.

Why Short-Term Fixes Hurt Long-Term Strategy

The saying “Culture eats strategy for breakfast” means that daily habits and company culture can override even the best business plans. In product data management, short-term solutions—like using Excel instead of a real system—end up blocking long-term success.

Small daily choices, like saving BOMs in Excel or emailing zip files, pile up into a big, messy system. If companies don’t change these habits, their data becomes a nightmare to manage.

The Result? A Big Mess

Over time, companies end up with what I call “product data spaghetti”—a tangled, confusing mess that no one can sort out. As a colleague reminded me recently, “Don’t break spaghetti!” In other words, keep things structured and organized. When data is messy, operations, procurement, and supply chains all suffer.

Even if engineers create amazing designs, bad data management can stop those designs from ever reaching customers. Manufacturing companies need a clear, organized approach to product data because everything—from production to sales—depends on it.

What is my conclusion?

Stop the Fast Food Habit. Companies must rethink how they handle product data. Excel and zip files may seem easy, but they cause problems in the long run. A solid data strategy helps keep everything running smoothly.

Without a clear plan, even the best designs won’t turn into successful products. So stop feeding your company fast food data management. Invest in a system that keeps things organized, accurate, and ready for success.

Just my thoughts…

Happy Friday!

Best, Oleg

Disclaimer: I’m the co-founder and CEO of OpenBOM, a digital-thread platform providing cloud-native collaborative services including PDM, PLM, and ERP capabilities. With extensive experience in federated CAD-PDM and PLM architecture, I’m advocates for agile, open product models and cloud technologies in manufacturing. My opinion can be unintentionally biased

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
5 June, 2009

I was reading Jos Voskuil’s post, “Where does PLM start beyond document management”. I think Jos raised a very valid...

4 December, 2014

Integration is a big deal. When it comes to enterprise organizations and specifically manufacturing companies of different kinds, enterprise integration...

31 March, 2015

I’m returning  home from CIMdata PLM market forum in Ann Arbor. For those of you who are not familiar with...

18 March, 2012

Well… I hope got some attention with this provoking title :). Social is trending topic these days. However, let me...

25 December, 2008

 As the New Year is very close, I see this ias a good time to dream about the future. Therefore,...

4 February, 2010

I want to discuss CAE today. CAE is considered as a technology to support engineers in tasks such as analysis,...

31 August, 2009

I’ve been reading blog post by Deelip related CATIA and SolidWorks and thought what can be the final solution for...

30 November, 2012

I just came back AU2012 in Las Vegas. Among many meetings, I had during AU, I attended Innovation Forum –...

26 August, 2009

PLM as a combination of technologies, software, and methodology came long way from initial CAD systems, followed by CAE, Product...

Blogroll

To the top