A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

PLM vs. ERP: Demand for Business Process

PLM vs. ERP: Demand for Business Process
olegshilovitsky
olegshilovitsky
2 September, 2009 | 2 min for reading

Picture 1I want to start today with twitter quote “PLM vs ERP – ERP a transactional system, not suited to manage development of product, integration of all info such as ingredients”. Well, PLM/PDM vs. ERP discussion is old, and I remember it for the last 10-15 years or even more… However, I’d expect some changes in this non-stop confrontation.

The original capabilities of PLM and ERP came respectfully out of their business roots – CAD Design/Data Management for PLM and manufacturing transaction from MRP/MRPII/ERP. However, both domains had demands to grow and make an expansion in organizations. PLM is looking for attractive domains such as requirements, manufacturing, supply chain. ERP is interested to expand toward product development. Both system domains (PLM and ERP) are looking how to establish connected space for enterprise organization business. So, how to achieve it?

I think, very interesting is that both classes of systems are very in favor of business processes. Even if PLM and ERP have a different notion of business processes, I’d say Business Processes can provide good synergy between both systems. PLM traditionally focused on very high level of people involvement in processes. Human based and hybrid processes is something that PLM requires. On the opposite side, ERP is focusing on automation and streamline of processes in organizations.

I think vendors on both (PLM and ERP) sides need to look very pro-actively how adopt Business Process Management technologies. This will be the key to success in organizations. From a technological standpoint, maturity of standards like BPMN and BPEL can provide a solid technological foundation for this work. But, at the same time, both PLM and ERP need to worry about growing capabilities of dedicated BPM vendors. They can take an attractive $$$ from aged PLM and ERP providers and establish strong BPM leadership in organization. I wrote about this in my previous PLM prompt.

So, what is my conclusion today? Business process have strong demand from both sides- PLM and ERP. The road toward successful BPM implementation can be very bumpy for PLM and ERP. Need to watch it out. Multiple vendors can still business and establish success business in front of enterprise behemoths.

What do you think about it? What are your practices with regards to process management in organization?

Best, Oleg

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
25 August, 2010

Have you had a chance to see any PLM strategic presentation? I’m sure you did. You can find easy few...

23 October, 2019

Digital Transformation is in the air. Every company these days is transforming itself into a future digital universe. There are...

22 August, 2010

An interesting report was published by SearchManufacturingERP.com few days ago – Report: Wider access to 3D CAD images can improve PLM...

8 October, 2015

Did you pay attention what happened to cloud storage? I’m sure you did. The cost is racing to zero. You...

6 October, 2011

Cloud is a hot topic these days. No, I’m not going to talk about True vs. False cloud and Mark...

24 September, 2021

Earlier this week, I attended the CIMdata PLM forum. You can find my first article with comments here – PLM...

26 October, 2017

Digital transformation and innovation are among  the most powerful trends you can hear these days. The traditional three letter acronyms...

12 March, 2020

Earlier last week, I attended the PTC Onshape Product Development Cloud Forum. Check out my article here () if you...

8 June, 2019

I spent the last three days at IDE 2019 – a summer school organized by Core-Lab of the University of...

Blogroll

To the top