A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

PLM-less AutoCAD Users And PLM Strategies?

PLM-less AutoCAD Users And PLM Strategies?
olegshilovitsky
olegshilovitsky
25 May, 2010 | 2 min for reading

A short note on WorldCAD Access by Ralf Grabowski got my attention few days ago. In a very competitive world of PLM, Ralf’s statement “PTC will bring PLM to… AutoCAD users” sounds very provoking.

I had chance to hear multiple discussions related to this topic. The most noted, in my view, is CIMData analytical work earlier this year – CIMData Entitles Autodesk’s Evolution as a PLM supplier.

I will try to clean up this space and discuss what is potential relationships between AutoCAD and PLM.

Organization, AutoCAD Users and PLM
AutoCAD is everywhere. I remember, somebody told me- you can find AutoCAD in every manufacturing organization in the world. Because of such wide adoption, every organization decided to create some of their products related information in AutoCAD. It can be data provided by suppliers, tools design and many others. For a company that doing all in 2D, AutoCAD can be still used as a design tool. In most of the cases, this status quo is absolutely not related with the potential interest of this company in Product Lifecycle Management implementation.

ProductPoint and PLM
Windchill ProductPoint implements an interesting strategy of bundling Microsoft’s SharePoint as a tool to manage CAD data, but not only. Because of wide SharePoint adoption, ProductPoint has a potential to find a path to user’s desktops in a much easier way. From the standpoint of PLM portfolio ProductPoint is just following CAD/PLM practice to get CAD data under control and enable collaboration.

PLM vision and CAD
CAD is playing a significant role in the mindshare of the top three PLM vendors. This vision primary came from CAD direction. The first objective for this type of the implementation is to get CAD data to be managed by PLM system. In my view, this strategy is different from more business oriented strategy in PLM proposed by non-CAD PLM vendors including ERP-PLM apps. There is nothing wrong with this strategy. However, it can steer PLM implementation goals from business direction and to focus on CAD data only.

What is my conclusion? Users are more interested in a practical outcome and less in marketing strategies.There are no dedicated “AutoCAD users” in an organization. Depending on the organization, people may use AutoCAD for multiple purposes, but in a manufacturing organization AutoCAD is just another tool to accomplish a task. AutoCAD data is only part of the overall product data. I think, users can appreciate the fact CAD files comes from multiple provides can be managed by a single system. So, nothing wrong with the ability of ProductPoint to manage AutoCAD files. Will it bring PLM to AutoCAD users? My guess is not. The PLM implementation is not about how to manage CAD files. However, this is an important step in the future ability to implement PLM strategy in the company.

Just my thoughts…
Best, Oleg

Share

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
30 December, 2010

I was reading Salesforce.com announcement made earlier this month during Dreamforce 2010 conference about introduction of a new database.com platform....

29 September, 2009

Interesting blog post from Google Enterprise. Import, Export and more with Google Sites API. What turns Google Sites to much...

28 May, 2022

Data is a very fascinating word. A few weeks ago, I was invited by Nina Dar to her Change Troubleshooter...

5 July, 2019

AI is a new trend. It brings a new wave of technological disruption across industries. Think about Web and Mobile...

7 December, 2018

For many years, PLM companies lived with the vision and value proposition of single source of truth (SSOT). Last month...

18 February, 2014

While industry is clearly moving to the cloud, the question about choosing right cloud model is getting more important. In my...

4 September, 2013

Data vs. Process. The egg or chicken of PLM industry. This topic is  near and dear to many people in...

23 May, 2010

Welcome to Beyond PLM! I will be starting blogging here very soon. For the moment, please check my Daily PLM...

14 September, 2017

To cloud or not to cloud? Few years ago, it was a question many engineering and manufacturing software companies were...

Blogroll

To the top