A blog by Oleg Shilovitsky
Information & Comments about Engineering and Manufacturing Software

PLM and Project Management Options

PLM and Project Management Options
Oleg
Oleg
19 October, 2010 | 2 min for reading

Few days ago, I run into Gartner Magic Quadrant about IT Project and Portfolio Management. You can get it by navigating to the following link (the link was live at the day I posted). Please take a read and make your opinion. Project and Portfolio management software is an interesting space, in my view. There are lots of vendors with very high level of diversification.

Customer Demands

This publication made me think about what are the customer options for PPM (Project and Portfolio Management). I think organizations are looking for this type of solutions today. The main reason is simple – it helps them to execute well. In product development, it becomes a very important tool to achieve their objectives.

PLM and Project Portfolio Management (PPM)

PLM PPM tools (sorry, I hate these TLAs) are becoming a normal part in a portfolio of PLM mind-share vendor. I’ve seen PLM vendors developed or acquired these functionality. You can find these products in the portfolio of ENOVIA (Program Central), TeamCenter (Program Portfolio Management), Windchill (ProjectLink) and in portfolios of other PLM and ERP vendors. I put examples of such applications in the following few videos.

TeamCenter
[youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=96jn_wZsp7w]

Aras Innovator
[youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FkDOv6mbU9k]

ENOVIA Program Central
[youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HF1uK–tqE0]

Project and Portfolio Management Tools

The Project and Portfolio Management tools covered by Gartner in this Magic-Q is representing a diverse set of applications. It scales from small niche players towards big superstars like Microsoft, HP, Oracle and others. Generally speaking all these tools are focused on how to gather data about project portfolio planning activities and make it available to people involved into this project. Now what happens if you are in an engineer involved into a product development project? You need to link somehow your engineering activities with project management. There is a certain disadvantage of most of these vendors in the inability to have deeper integration between project tools and engineering tools. On the other side, these independent vendors have a significant advantage in focusing on pure PPM functions. Some of the players (like Clarizen) have built a loosely coupled integration between CAD systems and their project management tools. You can take a look on a very nice demo of Clarizen working with AutoCAD.

What is my conclusion? In my view, the customer challenge is to choose between Integrated Products and separate Project Management Tools. In case you will pick up PLM Project Portfolio Management Tools, you are at the risk to stack with corporate wide deployment of this tool. In case of just picking up one of the available project management tools, you have a potential to stack in data integration between PDM/PLM modules and Project Management Tools. The decision is yours and probably very individual. I’m interested to hear your opinion and please, share your experience.

Best, Oleg

Recent Posts

Also on BeyondPLM

4 6
15 August, 2021

Data is one of the most critical assets in every business these days. As much as everyone speaks about the...

10 March, 2024

The discussion about engineers preferring to use spreadsheets, while PLM function is always introducing some sort of governance and business...

27 September, 2016

My attention was caught by Engineering.com article – eBook: Putting PLM Within Reach. The write-up introduces Jim Brown’s ebook. The...

17 October, 2022

Last week, I was recording a video podcast with Adam Keating, CEO of CoLab. We discussed modern tech trends, and...

8 April, 2010

I’d like to come with questions about the topic of PLM and Data Modeling. The idea of this discussion came...

5 May, 2010

User experience is important. It comes with all cool gadgets, Web 2.0 websites and iPhone apps. I think, people started...

30 May, 2010

I read an interesting note from Autodesk Labs. Inventor 2011 now available for trials via the cloud. It made me...

30 March, 2010

Thanks for one of my readers who sent me the link to Wrench Enterprise. Their presentation about project collaboration and...

30 July, 2014

Security. It is hard to underestimate the importance of the topic. Information is one of the biggest assets companies have....

Blogroll

To the top